In the final results of All-Star voting, Josh Hamilton has been selected as the third starter in this year’s game in St. Louis. Clearly, this selection is based on last year’s performance and not on what he has done this year.
Last year, Josh hit .304 with 32 home runs and 13o RBI. Clearly a sensational season. And, perhaps more important in his nationwide appeal, he put on a spectacular display of power in the Home Run Derby of the 2008 All-Star festivities.
This year, however, has been plagued by injury and average statistics. He’s currently on rehab making his way back from abdominal surgery on June 9. He has played in only 35 games, hitting .240 with just six home runs and 24 RBI.
Obviously, his appearance in this year’s game will be a gift of the fan vote. He would not have been selected by the players or by manager Joe Maddon without it. Torii Hunter or Carl Crawford would have been much more deserving selections based on this year’s performance.


















July 7th, 2009 at 7:11 PM
I agree with your take 100%. These are the type of inadequacies that mlb should fix. Don’t some of these fans have any clue at all….. I guess we already answered that.